by Ken Toole | Nov 10, 2026 | Elections
The weirdest election in recent memory has drawn to a close. The finger-pointing and recriminations have begun. The contention is likely to reverberate in Democratic circles for some time to come. In this election, “Independent” activists, including many former Democratic leaders, attacked the Democratic nominee. They also attacked the Democratic Party and used their power and connections to persuade donors not to support the party’s electoral programs.
I agree with those who said the Democratic primary candidates were not strong contenders to take on Steve Daines or Kurt Alme, for that matter (apologies to Bankhead and Neill). I voted for Black Wolf in the primary. I voted for Bankhead in the general election. This wasn’t the first time I had doubts about a Democratic nominee’s ability to win or outright disagreed with their positions on policy issues.
Setting aside the effect of piles of dirty money, particularly in the Democratic primary, lots of people are asking why Democrats couldn’t field stronger candidates. In a typical election cycle, a lot of effort goes into candidate recruitment. The major player is typically the Democratic Party along with its allies. It develops lists of potential candidates, urges them to run, and helps them navigate the process of organizing campaigns. Obviously, there are plenty of people who decide to run without being urged by the Party, but even these candidates often turn to the Party for advice and support. Even candidates at the top of the ticket, who often don’t need much persuasion to run, still turn to party structures for support, often through local central committees.
Candidate Profiles and Electability
In this process, people talk a lot about “candidate profiles,” looking for people to run who are considered “electable.” This imaginary electable candidate in Montana has been dominated by a centrist profile: a businessman, a veteran, a farmer or rancher, someone who goes huntin’ and fishin’ and supports the Second Amendment. You get the idea. The farther up the ballot you go, the more people seem to be committed to this profile. Potential candidates who fit the profile are encouraged; people who don’t are discouraged. Not surprisingly, the more progressive candidates, who tend to break the mold, have been women.
We have ended up with a pretty narrow slice of the population viewed as electable in Montana by many party activists, political consultants, and statewide elected officials. Obviously, this is at the root of the decision by many of them to support an Independent. That, and the tons of money available to try the “independent experiment” here in Montana.
There Are Plenty of Viable Democrats in Montana
But despite what people say, Democrats did not lack people who could have been stronger contenders in the Senate election. Here are just a few names. (Disclaimer: This list is neither comprehensive nor an endorsement.)
Russell Cleveland, John Morrison, Ryan Busse, Monica Tranel, Raph Graybill, Cora Neumann, Whitney Williams, Melissa Romano, Shane Morigeau, and John Heenan.
Ironically, some of the most visible endorsers of Seth Bodnar in this election were eligible to run themselves. These include Jon Tester (he was eligible but maybe not popular since disclosure that he is now working for Peter Thiel and Palantir), Steve Bullock, Nancy Keenan, Mike Cooney, and Denise Juneau.
In addition, Montana has strong leaders in advocacy groups like labor, conservation, trial lawyers, and Native communities. Add to that county commissions, city councils, and various governmental boards and advisory committees. With hindsight, it is pretty obvious that quite a few of these folks would have won in the blue wave that just washed over us without an independent on the ballot..
Group Think Is a Powerful Thing
After a string of lost elections, lots of people concluded that a Democrat cannot win a statewide election in Montana. In the rarified environment of organizing and executing big campaigns, Montana consultants, current and former Democratic elected officials, representatives of major funders, and some pollsters sat around tables, stroking their chins and nodding, reinforcing that idea.
And they decided to do something about it: run a centrist Independent. Never mind the obvious building blue wave in this election cycle.
Now, entering this picture is poor Seth Bodnar. He is a political centrist with no electoral experience, and he was their candidate of choice. He had all of the profile points these folks were looking for. Rumor has it that Bodnar was preparing to announce as a Democrat when a small group of people with lots of political experience and connections to big money met with him. On their advice, he decided to run as an Independent. In time, that story is bound to be told.
I’m not a fan of sports analogies, but one seems appropriate here. Imagine a team in the locker room with the coach giving his inspirational speech: “Let’s get out there. We can’t win this thing!”
As they run out onto the field, the cheerleaders jump up, waving their pom-poms, and lead the crowd in a cheer: “We can’t win! We can’t win!”
There is no mystery about why Democrats have trouble recruiting good candidates. It’s time to send the Eeyores back to their house at Pooh Corner.
by Guest Cartoonist | Nov 5, 2026 | Democrats, Elections
Guest Cartoonist, John Moore
November 5, 2026
by Ken Toole | Oct 30, 2026 | Democrats, Elections, Republicans
Elections are usually nasty things. As we get closer to Election Day, they tend to get nastier. “The big lies” start circulating about candidates, and complaints—or threats of complaints—get filed with enforcement agencies. Early in campaigns, candidates put out glowing accounts of their backgrounds and what they hope to accomplish if elected. But as campaigns drag on, other players enter the arena to promote their own agendas and preferred candidates, most often without disclosing to the public who they really are.
And campaigns have gotten dirtier these days. There are lots of reasons for that, but two stand out. The first is social media, which provides an immediate and often unaccountable platform for people to spout off. In some ways, that is good. In others, such as the ease with which lies about candidates can spread, it is not.
The bigger issue, however, is big money—some of it so-called dark money and some of it not. The amount of money pouring into elections has become overwhelming since the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision allowed virtually unlimited independent spending in political campaigns.
First, Let’s Talk About the Republicans
In Montana, Republicans have been engaged in an internal blood feud for years. Despite their complete domination of public offices in Montana, they have stumbled and flailed, creating great political theater for many of us while failing to govern effectively. Under their watch, Montana is turning into Mississippi Northwest, with struggling schools, closures of rural hospitals and nursing homes, and skyrocketing utility bills. Meanwhile, all they seem to talk about is cutting taxes further, protecting gun rights, and the so-called “threat” of trans athletes.
In this election, Kurt Alme and Steve Daines colluded to deprive Republican primary voters of a choice in the election. To remind folks, since many of us have spent the last couple of months watching the brush fire in the Democratic Party, Daines resigned his Senate seat at the last minute, and Alme was the only candidate to file in the final minutes before the deadline.
Switcheroo! Sorry, Republican voters—no choice for you. Maybe you’ll get to vote on Steve Daines in the next primary, when he will likely be a candidate for governor.
Now, About Those Democrats
After a long string of lost elections, former Democratic officeholders were tired and angry. Then some members of the Democratic “A Team” simply took the ball and walked off the field. They joined another team, leaving many rank-and-file Democrats confused and angry.
Adding insult to injury, the former Democratic “A Team” constructed an elaborate conspiracy that tested the boundaries of law and ethics in an effort to place a stalking horse at the top of the Democratic ticket. The conspiracy, like almost all conspiracies, collapsed under the weight of its own hubris and arrogance. Their stalking horse, Alani Bankhead, refused to resign and leave the field open for their new team member, independent Seth Bodnar.
The Montana “A Team” effort is part of a growing national movement of independent candidates. There are somewhere around 200 independent candidates currently running for federal office, a record number. Unfortunately, the most prominent person organizing these candidates is former West Virginia Senator “King of Coal” Joe Manchin. (See our previous post: https://wtf406.com/?s=Bodnar+)
Manchin’s political group, the Independent Leadership Council, has been pouring money into Bodnar’s campaign. Meanwhile, Bodnar’s campaign, which is theoretically focused on recruiting disaffected Democratic and Republican voters, appears far more interested in attacking Democrat Alani Bankhead than Republican Kurt Alme.
The result of all this for the Democratic Party is chaos—and a loss of resources.
When it appeared that Bankhead would refuse to resign, Bodnar supporters mounted an aggressive campaign to pressure her and the Democratic Party Executive Board. Part of that effort involved urging donors not to contribute to the party or asking them to reclaim their contributions.
So, while the spotlight is on this fight at the top of the ticket, down-ballot races have suffered as well. The Montana Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee, which provides support for local legislative races, is underfunded thanks to pressure put on it’s donors by Bodnar supporters. Hard to say how the Democratic Coordinated Campaign which has traditionally coordinated campaigns at the top of the ticket is operating, if at all. This effort has traditionally been supported, in part, by the campaigns. Given the chaos and animosity among Democrats in this election it’s hard to imagine that either Bankhead or Brian Miller would be contributing to that kind of coordinated effort.
Whether this has influenced Sam Forstag’s race in the Western Congressional District is unknown and will remain unknown. But perhaps the most damaging consequence is the way this turmoil reinforces public cynicism about politics.
All of this damage to the Democrats has been done, whether Seth Bodnar wins or loses.
What’s at Stake in This Election?
Unfortunately, all this maneuvering within the Democratic Party is taking place in the midst of a national crisis. Our national government has been taken over by an unhinged authoritarian. The Republican Party has dutifully fallen in line behind his agenda of bigoted violence in our streets and wars in other countries. Republicans have tolerated the open grift and graft involving his family members, their foreign and domestic cronies, and the entire class of American oligarchs. Meanwhile, middle-class Americans confront rampant inflation, declining access to health care, a lack of child care, and a host of other problems.
The good news is that a “blue wave” is coming in this election. At this writing, it appears that the U.S. House of Representatives will flip to Democratic control. The Senate is also up for grabs, according to polling. If Democrats take control, they will have their hands full digging the rats out of the corners of our national government.
But while the blue wave roils around us in places like Texas, Alaska, Kansas, Michigan, and Maine, here in Montana, we’ll be standing on our red island, watching our best opportunity in years wash away in the surf.
by Guest Writer | Oct 21, 2026 | Democrats, Elections, Independent
Guest Post By Russell Cleveland
U.S. Navy Veteran and Former Congressional Candidate
There is something the military teaches you about leadership that stays with you long after you take off the uniform.
You don’t abandon your post when things get difficult.
When tensions rise, when the bombs begin falling, when relationships are strained and the mission seems impossible, that is when leadership matters most. Not when victory seems certain, but when everything around you is being tested.
I’ve been thinking about that lesson following Shannon O’Brien’s resignation as chair of the Montana Democratic Party.
Let me be clear: This isn’t about supporting a Democrat or an independent candidate for the United States Senate. Montanans value independent thinking, and I respect everyone’s right to support the candidate they believe will best represent our state.
This is about the responsibility we accept when we ask others to trust us with leadership.
In September 2025, I proudly voted for Mike Jopek to lead the Montana Democratic Party and encouraged others to do the same. Not because I believed he would always make popular decisions, but because I believed he understood what our party desperately needed: rebuilding trust, reconnecting with working families, and restoring purpose to an organization that had lost its footing with too many Montanans.
My concerns about party leadership began long before this resignation.
In spring 2025, as I launched my congressional campaign, I approached O’Brien seeking guidance and a working relationship. Instead, I left disappointed by the lack of meaningful support and direction.
Later, during conversations about data center development, I understood from party leadership that pressure from organized labor discouraged candidates from publicly challenging certain developments, with union support potentially at stake.
I deeply respect organized labor. But supporting unions should never require candidates to surrender their independence or remain silent about issues affecting Montana communities. Leadership should help candidates navigate difficult conversations, not discourage them from having them.
Now, just weeks before an election, we face another test.
I recognize the complexity of Montana’s Senate race. A qualified, well-funded independent candidate has complicated an already difficult political landscape. But the responsibility of a state party chair was never limited to one Senate race.
Across Montana, dedicated Democratic candidates are sacrificing time with their families, knocking on doors, and fighting for communities they love. They deserve leadership that stands beside them, especially when circumstances become uncomfortable.
And the opportunity before Montana Democrats extends far beyond November.
Across America, political frustration has created an opening to reconnect with working people who feel abandoned by both parties. Montana families are struggling with housing, healthcare, wages, and the growing influence of wealthy interests over government.
We should be rebuilding relationships with ranchers, farmers, veterans, tradespeople, teachers, and small-business owners. Instead, too much energy has been consumed by internal conflict and political calculations.
I don’t question O’Brien’s right to follow her conscience, nor should her years of public service be dismissed. But compassion and accountability are not mutually exclusive.
Leadership carries obligations beyond personal preference.
I’ve spent much of my adult life building organizations, employing people, raising a family, and serving my community. I’ve made mistakes and faced criticism. But I’ve learned that leadership isn’t measured by how many people agree with you when things are easy.
It’s measured by whether people can count on you when things become difficult.
Montana Democrats can rebuild. But doing so requires humility, courage, and remembering that political parties exist to serve people, not preserve power.
To every candidate still knocking on doors, every volunteer still making calls, and every Montanan who believes public service can be honorable: Keep going.
Your work matters. Your communities matter.
Because when the mission becomes difficult, that isn’t the time to abandon your post.
It’s the time to remember why you volunteered to serve in the first place.
by Ken Toole | Oct 18, 2026 | Corruption, Elections, Independent
Careful What You Wish For . . .
The latest fad in American politics is candidates who claim to be independent of political parties. Conjuring images of potbellied, cigar-smoking party bosses from the late 19th century, these candidates proclaim that their only interest is in the welfare of the “average, everyday voter.” In truth, their only accountability is to the donors who pay their bills.
Frustration Is Generating More Interest in Independent Candidates
On the national level, more than 200 independents are running for the U.S. House and Senate, a record number. Even those of us who have been engaged in politics for years are sick of the bickering and badgering that have taken over our political system. The toxic influence of money has turned our political system into a hotbed of crony capitalism and cynical manipulation of public opinion.
While it appears that this surge of independent candidates is spontaneous, plenty of people in politics understand the potential power of a bloc of votes in Congress that does not align itself with either major political party. Many of those people are working to advance what has become known as the “Fulcrum Strategy.” The idea is that a small, disciplined bloc of independent or third-party legislators can control policy outcomes by tipping the balance of power between the political parties. It’s simple and potentially effective.
Probably the most prominent group supporting this strategy has been the Forward Party, founded in 2021 by former presidential candidate Andrew Yang, former New Jersey Governor Christine Todd Whitman, and businessman Michael Willner. Its slogan is Not Left, Not Right, Forward. On September 23 to 25 the Independent National Convention was held in Washington DC. Montana’s two independent candidates, Seth Bodnar and Michael Eisenhauer attended.
In this election cycle, others have joined the movement to promote independent candidates. Among those is the Independent Leadership Council which has been pouring money into Bodnar’s race. (See our previous post about Seth Bodnar’s participation in a group founded by Joe Manchin, the former independent senator from West Virginia: Seth Bodnar . . . Teaming Up With Joe Manchin?.)
Who Are Independent Candidates Really Accountable To?
Before jumping on the independent bandwagon, there are a few things to consider. First among them is this: How accountable to the “average, everyday voter” is an independent candidate?
The truth is that running for office, particularly federal office, is extremely expensive. The unprecedented maneuvering in our Senate race has been driven by money from political action committees and other “dark money” groups. Some of these groups are aligned with traditional partisan interests, while others represent players who are relatively new to politics. But all of these donors expect something in return for their investment in candidates. That is true of independents, Republicans, and Democrats alike.
No matter what you think about our major political parties, they provide mechanisms for holding candidates and officeholders accountable beyond the cold, hard cash. Both parties have local central committees populated by volunteers who live in the communities they represent. These local organizations often provide many of the volunteers who form the backbone of local and statewide campaigns.
Both parties have written rules and by-laws which govern their activities. They hold conventions to elect officers and develop positions on issues they care about. These conventions are open to party members. Both parties also develop platforms of positions on various issues at member conventions that are available to the public. None of this exists for independent candidates or officeholders.
It’s worth noting that the current controversy within the Montana Democratic Party is not unique to Democrats. Republicans are mired in an internal blood feud that has been going on for years and virtually paralyzed the last legislature. Despite Republicans’ electoral success in Montana, they are failing to govern effectively. (See our previous posts on the Republican Party: There’s Nothing New About This Montana Republican Party and Dispatches From the Republican Civil War.)
Our Democratic Leaders Blew It In This Election
We’re not blind to the problems with our two-party system. The United States Supreme Court dealt a death blow to our political system with the Citizens United decision, which opened the floodgates to a torrent of dirty money flowing into elections. The reality is that we now do our political work under an authoritarian regime run for and by oligarchs. The next two elections may be our last chance to change what looks like a very dark future. And our Democratic leaders, people rank and file Montana Democrats have supported for years, blew it in this election. Hopefully, the rest of the country can do better.
The solution is not to create a cabal of nonaligned “independent” players who broker political deals with relatively little public engagement. Far better to strengthen and unify the traditional system, which has worked imperfectly for decades, and to get the massive amounts of money out of our political process.
by Guest Cartoonist | Oct 9, 2026 | Elections
Guest Cartoonist, John Moore
October 9, 2026